New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani is under significant scrutiny after a video resurfaced from a 2023 conference where he compared the New York Police Department (NYPD) to the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). This statement has reignited criticism of his previous comments about law enforcement, prompting calls for clarification on his stance.
The clip, which emerged from the Democratic Socialists of America national convention, features Mamdani stating, “When the boot of the NYPD is on your neck, it’s been laced by the IDF.” His remarks have led to widespread condemnation across social media, with varying opinions emerging among commentators and public figures.
During a recent event in Hell’s Kitchen, Mamdani addressed the backlash, stating, “I’m looking forward to working with police officers here in New York City to deliver public safety.” He emphasized the need to tackle the “retention crisis,” noting that approximately 350 officers are leaving the department each month. Mamdani pointed out that police should focus strictly on law enforcement rather than social service responsibilities.
His past statements, including calls for the NYPD to be defunded, have drawn further criticism. During the same panel discussion, Mamdani sought to contextualize his analogy by emphasizing the need for local and international issues to be interconnected.
Mamdani’s comments have elicited strong reactions. Clay Travis, founder of Outkick.com, labeled Mamdani’s remarks as “textbook antisemitism” and questioned the sincerity of his apology to the NYPD. Likewise, Jonathan Greenblatt, CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, condemned the comments, stating they reflect “twisted fear-mongering.”
Responses from political figures have also been critical. Andrew Cuomo, former Governor of New York, expressed concerns over Mamdani’s divisive rhetoric, arguing that unity is essential for effective leadership in a diverse city like New York. He remarked, “You can’t be a divisive leader in this city. You have to be united.”
Mamdani’s proposals for policing have stirred further debate. He has suggested that social workers should manage certain 911 calls to reduce the burden on the NYPD, a plan he has advocated since 2020. Critics, including retired NYPD Sergeant Joseph Giacalone, have dismissed this idea as impractical, warning of the potential consequences if dispatchers misjudge a situation.
The controversy surrounding Mamdani highlights a growing divide in public perception regarding law enforcement and community safety. As the mayoral race progresses, his ability to navigate these complex discussions will likely play a crucial role in shaping his campaign.
With election day approaching, Mamdani will need to address not only his past statements but also the broader implications of his proposals for law enforcement in New York City.