Vanity Fair is experiencing significant internal turmoil following discussions about featuring First Lady Melania Trump on its cover. Editor-in-Chief Mark Guiducci, who took the helm in June after departing from Vogue, is reportedly pushing for broader representation of cultural figures from the political right. This move has prompted backlash from many staff members, leading to threats of resignation.
Guiducci’s ambition to include Melania Trump on the cover has ignited outrage among employees, particularly those aligned with more liberal viewpoints. According to a report by Semafor, some staff members are willing to resign if the cover comes to fruition. One mid-level editor expressed strong sentiments, stating, “I will walk out the motherf—ing door, and half my staff will follow me.” This editor emphasized the importance of standing against what they perceive as the normalization of the Trump administration.
Despite the fervent reactions from certain employees, not all are ready to take such drastic measures. A different staff member commented, “If they put her on the cover, people will protest and gripe about it, but I don’t see anyone quitting such a prestigious job over that.” They suggested that the ultimate decision rests with Guiducci, who will bear the consequences of any potential backlash.
Historically, Melania Trump has not been featured on the covers of Vanity Fair or Vogue during her husband’s presidency. In contrast, her Democratic predecessors, including Michelle Obama, Jill Biden, and Hillary Clinton, have all graced the cover of Vogue, with Obama appearing three times.
While Melania Trump, a former model, has previously made cover appearances, she has expressed indifference towards the significance of magazine features. In a past interview, she stated, “Look, I’ve been there on the covers — on the cover of Vogue, on the covers of many magazines before. We have so many other important things to do than to be on the cover of any magazine.”
As the situation unfolds, it remains to be seen how Guiducci will navigate the competing interests within the magazine. His decision could have lasting implications not only for the publication’s editorial direction but also for employee morale.
The debate at Vanity Fair highlights broader tensions within the media industry regarding representation and the portrayal of political figures. As discussions continue, the outcome may reflect the evolving landscape of political representation in high-profile publications.