UPDATE: Critical missteps by police are now central to the felony burglary trial of Sen. Nicole Mitchell, DFL-Woodbury, as new evidence emerged during testimony. The trial, unfolding in Detroit Lakes, is focused on the alleged break-in at the home of her stepmother, Carol Mitchell, on April 22, 2024.
In a dramatic turn of events, police admitted to failing to secure vital evidence that could impact the jury’s decision. During questioning, Becker County Attorney Brian McDonald confronted Detroit Lakes Police Chief Steven Todd, who acknowledged several errors in the investigation. “Are there a few items that you wish we had done differently?” McDonald asked. Todd’s response was a candid “Yes.”
Among the mishandled evidence was a note found in Mitchell’s backpack, which contained alarming phrases like “delete texts” and “add tracking Gmail.” Despite the note’s potential significance, it was never logged into evidence, raising questions about police procedure.
The trial revealed that officers also returned a pair of black “flashlight gloves” to Mitchell, which could indicate intent to commit theft under the cover of darkness. Todd expressed regret for this oversight, highlighting the lack of thoroughness in the investigation.
Furthermore, no search was conducted on Mitchell’s vehicle, and there was no warrant obtained to examine her phone for additional evidence. Todd admitted to these shortcomings, stating, “That was a mistake.”
Adding to the complexity, a prybar found outside the home, which could link Mitchell to the scene, was also mishandled. Officer Ethan Wothe testified that he picked it up with his bare hands during a bodycam recording, acknowledging it was not best practice.
The defense is trying to establish that Nicole Mitchell was concerned for her stepmother’s well-being, as Carol suffers from Alzheimer’s disease, and was conducting a welfare check after failing to get in touch for weeks. The prosecution has rested its case, and the defense has begun calling witnesses to support their narrative.
Nicole Mitchell faces severe consequences if convicted. She could be sentenced to a maximum of 20 years for first-degree burglary and up to 3 years for possession of burglary tools. As the trial progresses, the potential for her to testify remains uncertain, but her attorneys indicate she is eager to share her side of the story.
This case has captivated public attention, not only due to Mitchell’s political standing but also the implications of police accountability in criminal investigations. As the jury deliberates the evidence presented, many are left wondering how these revelations will influence their decision.
Stay tuned for further updates as this trial unfolds.