UPDATE: A shocking scene unfolded at Angel Paws Pet Cremation in San Marcos, California, where owner Christopher Settle was arrested on November 14, 2023, for alleged grand theft. Authorities report that Settle collected payments for cremations, yet left pets to decompose in freezers, distributing false ashes to grieving clients.
The San Diego County Sheriff’s Department confirmed Settle’s arrest outside his home in Temecula, following a warrant issued in North County Superior Court. He was released on bond the following day and is scheduled for a court appearance on December 10.
This disturbing case has been under scrutiny since early this year when clients voiced concerns on social media, noting that they were unable to retrieve their pets’ remains. Reports indicate that the local power company cut off gas and electricity to Angel Paws on July 9 due to missed payments, leaving pets’ bodies to rot for up to five months.
An affidavit revealed that Settle’s incinerator operating permit expired in March 2024. In late September, several former clients confronted Settle, demanding answers. Initially unresponsive, he eventually allowed them into the facility, where Gerry Wellman, owner of a local cremation company, described a “grisly” scene of stacked, partially frozen pet remains.
“It’s just a fiasco,” Wellman stated, emphasizing the emotional toll on grieving pet owners. “People were waiting for their loved ones’ ashes and got nothing. The worst thing you could do is not answer them or lie.”
Wellman stepped in to assist with the cremation of remaining bodies. He revealed shocking details: “The owner of Angel Paws called me to drop off 20 pets he couldn’t cremate. He showed up with a U-Haul truck containing over 40 pets, some in deplorable condition.”
The impact on the community is profound, with Wellman receiving up to 15 calls a day from affected families. “Victims feel defrauded and believe everyone involved missed the signs,” he said. “The area around the building smelled awful, like throw-up.”
One devastated pet owner, Denise Parker, recounted her experience during the September confrontation, stating she discovered her pet’s body among the chaos, contrary to claims that she had received its ashes. “The smell was horrific,” Parker told CBS8. “Bodies were laying in the freezer, not even bagged up — just laying on top of others.”
Authorities urge anyone with information or former clients of Angel Paws to contact the San Marcos Sheriff’s Station at (760) 510-5200.
As this case unfolds, the emotional and legal ramifications for those affected are significant. Stay tuned for further developments as this troubling story continues to evolve.