UPDATE: The New York Red Bulls have officially been eliminated from playoff contention, marking the end of their record-breaking 15-year postseason streak. This shocking development follows the Chicago Fire’s thrilling 5-3 victory over Inter Miami on Tuesday night, which sealed the Red Bulls’ fate.
This season’s outcome is particularly devastating for fans, as it represents the first time since 2009 that the Red Bulls will not compete in the MLS playoffs. Earlier this year, the team generated excitement by reaching the MLS Cup Final, but their hopes have since crumbled amid a tumultuous 2025 season characterized by injuries and inconsistent performances.
Red Bulls head coach Sandro Schwarz expressed his disappointment, stating,
“I know everyone is disappointed to maybe not have the qualification for the playoffs. I’m the first one about that. But I would say, [there] was some injuries and without some moments…[the current situation] for me is not the biggest surprise right now.”
Schwarz emphasized that the team will continue to fight until the end of the season.
The Red Bulls needed the Fire to lose to maintain a slim chance for the playoffs after suffering a loss to rival New York City FC over the weekend. The pressure was high, but their hopes were dashed with the Fire’s decisive win.
Injuries have plagued the Red Bulls this season, particularly the loss of star player Lewis Morgan, sidelined since June due to a quad injury. The club’s struggle to secure additional talent during the summer transfer window, including the failure to acquire Timo Werner from RB Leipzig, has left the team lacking the necessary firepower.
Looking ahead, the Red Bulls have one final home game scheduled against Cincinnati on Saturday, October 7, 2025, before they wrap up the season on the road in Columbus. Fans and analysts alike are left to ponder what changes will come for the team in the off-season as they seek to rebuild and restore their playoff presence.
This unexpected elimination not only marks a significant moment for the Red Bulls but also sends ripples through the MLS community, highlighting the unpredictable nature of professional sports. As the team reflects on this disappointing chapter, fans are eager to see how management will respond and what new strategies will be implemented moving forward.