The Ohio State Buckeyes faced off against the Indiana Hoosiers in the Big Ten Championship on December 6, 2025, but fell short in a game that raised questions about their offensive strategy. The Buckeyes, ranked No. 2 in the nation, kept their offensive approach conservative throughout the game, a choice that has sparked debate among fans and analysts alike.
During the regular season, Ohio State’s offense appeared to operate in a lower gear, winning twelve games with minimal pressure. They dominated approximately 42 out of 48 quarters, thanks in part to a formidable defense. This allowed them to practice against a level of competition that was often superior to their actual opponents. The Buckeyes faced a challenging slate in the postseason, encountering Indiana, a team that had established itself as a significant contender.
Ohio State’s decision to rely on a conservative game plan against Indiana was evident. The Buckeyes’ offense featured a lesser-used tight end more prominently, limiting the effectiveness of their star receivers. This tactical choice allowed Indiana’s defense to maintain its preferred 4-3 formation throughout the game, effectively neutralizing Ohio State’s offensive threats.
In a post-game analysis, Ohio State head coach Ryan Day emphasized the need for efficiency, stating, “That’s how you control the game. When it’s time to turn up the gas, we will.” Yet, the Buckeyes’ lack of urgency during the game led many to question whether they had underestimated their opponent. The Hoosiers, under head coach Curt Cignetti, showcased an aggressive offensive strategy that contrasted sharply with Ohio State’s approach.
The Buckeyes’ play calling drew criticism, especially when they opted for heavier formations that limited their speed and versatility. Julian Sayin, Ohio State’s quarterback and Heisman Trophy finalist, struggled to find rhythm against Indiana’s mixed coverages and pressure. The game became a litmus test for Ohio State’s postseason readiness, with many wondering if they would continue to employ a conservative strategy in the upcoming Cotton Bowl.
As the Buckeyes prepare for their next challenge, the perception is that they must shift gears to showcase their full potential. The performance against Indiana revealed vulnerabilities in their play style, suggesting that a more aggressive approach may be necessary to compete effectively in the College Football Playoff.
The implications of this game extend beyond just one loss. Ohio State’s coaching decisions and offensive strategy will be scrutinized as they look to regain their momentum. The upcoming Cotton Bowl will serve as a critical juncture for the Buckeyes, who must decide whether to continue this conservative approach or unleash their full capabilities on a national stage. This decision will not only affect their immediate future but could also shape the trajectory of the program moving forward.