The upcoming 2025-26 NHL season brings heightened expectations for numerous players across the league. While every player endures some degree of pressure, certain individuals stand out as facing significant scrutiny. Here are the 20 NHL players who are under the most pressure as they prepare for the upcoming season.
Connor McDavid: The Countdown Continues
Connor McDavid, often hailed as the best player of his generation, is still in pursuit of that elusive Stanley Cup. Despite his remarkable skill and achievements, including multiple Hart Trophies, McDavid risks being remembered as one of the greatest players never to win a championship. Having made two finals appearances that ended in defeat, the pressure is mounting as he approaches his prime years.
Edmonton Oilers’ Goaltending Woes
Stuart Skinner represents a pivotal figure for the Edmonton Oilers, who are eager to capitalize on their championship window. The franchise’s goaltending struggles in recent years have frustrated fans and analysts alike. If Skinner can provide reliable performance, the Oilers may finally secure a title. However, another disappointing season could see Skinner facing intense blame.
Mitch Marner, who recently signed an eight-year, $96 million deal with the Vegas Golden Knights, is under immense scrutiny following his departure from a Toronto team desperate for a Cup. With Marner’s potential to deliver results, fans are eager to see if he can replicate his prior success while navigating the expectations of a new market.
The Golden Knights’ acquisition of Marner has resulted in heightened expectations for Matthew Knies, who must now step up in Toronto. Having recorded 29 goals last season, Knies faces the challenge of filling the void left by Marner, who amassed 102 points in the previous year.
Legacy on the Line for Goaltenders
For Connor Hellebuyck, the pressure mounts as he seeks to improve his playoff performance. Despite winning three Vezina Trophies and being recognized as one of the greatest American goalies, Hellebuyck’s postseason statistics have raised concerns. With a GAA exceeding 3.00 in recent playoffs, he needs to elevate his game when it matters most.
Similarly, the Washington Capitals are looking to Dylan Strome to help lead the team during this critical phase of Alex Ovechkin‘s career. As the Capitals aim for one last championship run, Strome’s role as the number-one center will be crucial in setting up Ovechkin and providing the necessary support for a deep playoff push.
In Carolina, Martin Necas faces his own pressure after being traded during a pivotal moment in the franchise’s history. With expectations to replace a high-scoring player like Mikko Rantanen, Necas must prove his worth by contributing significantly to the Hurricanes’ playoff ambitions.
Veterans with Something to Prove
Steven Stamkos, a seasoned veteran who joined the Nashville Predators after a long tenure with the Tampa Bay Lightning, is under pressure to validate the team’s investment in him. With his 34th birthday approaching and expectations for continued high-level performance, Stamkos seeks to demonstrate that he can still be a valuable asset.
The situation surrounding Charlie McAvoy is critical as the Boston Bruins transition from Cup contenders to a rebuilding phase. As a potential captain and key defenseman, McAvoy’s performance is paramount for the franchise’s future success.
Meanwhile, Dylan Larkin bears the weight of leadership for the Detroit Red Wings, who have missed the playoffs for nine consecutive seasons. As the team’s captain, Larkin’s effectiveness will be scrutinized, especially given the franchise’s rich history of success.
Young Stars Under Heavy Expectations
Buffalo Sabres defenseman Owen Power faces pressure to justify his first-overall selection in the draft. As the Sabres strive to break a 14-season playoff drought, Power’s development and performance will play a crucial role in the team’s success.
In Montreal, Sam Montembeault is tasked with providing stability in goal after the Canadiens’ surprising playoffs run last season. Reliable goaltending could be the missing piece for a team with championship aspirations.
Jack Hughes, a standout player for the New Jersey Devils, aims to overcome injury concerns that have limited his ice time. A full season of health could significantly impact the team’s playoff chances.
In Vancouver, Elias Pettersson must rebound from a challenging season to solidify his status as the Canucks’ offensive centerpiece. With pressure mounting, he must deliver strong performances to silence critics.
As a previous Norris Trophy winner, Adam Fox is under scrutiny to maintain his level of play and help the New York Rangers secure playoff success. His offensive contributions from the blue line will be closely monitored.
Lastly, Connor Bedard and Matty Beniers represent the new generation of talent in the NHL. While Bedard faces expectations to become a franchise cornerstone, Beniers, as a Calder Trophy winner, needs to lead the Seattle Kraken into playoff contention.
Each of these players carries a unique set of expectations and pressures heading into the 2025-26 NHL season. Their performances will not only impact their respective teams but also shape their legacies in the league.