On September 23, 2025, a significant chapter of New Iberia’s lore was officially recognized with the installation of a historical marker at the former Mount Carmel on Duperier Drive. Funded by the William G. Pomeroy Foundation, this event celebrated the local legend of the “Bayou Teche tunnel,” which is said to have provided an escape route for the infamous pirate Jean Lafitte.
The plaque installation brought together public officials and former students of Mount Carmel, marking an important moment in the community’s effort to preserve its unique history. The Legends and Lore Marker Grant Program, which aims to highlight stories tied to specific locations—regardless of their historical accuracy—was integral to this celebration.
Honoring Local Legends
John Sharp, assistant director for the Center for Louisiana Studies, emphasized the value of storytelling within communities. “The important thing is that there’s this story and you as a community have continued to tell it, that’s what is important,” he stated. The Center for Louisiana Studies collaborates with the William G. Pomeroy Foundation to install such markers across the state, including in places like Eunice and Natchitoches, where local legends have thrived.
The legend surrounding Jean Lafitte is rooted in a small room beneath the Mount Carmel building. When current owner Herman Schellstede acquired the property, he was informed of its historical significance, including the tale of Lafitte’s escape through a tunnel connected to the Bayou Teche. This room features a trap door and an opening leading directly to the bayou, where it is said that Lafitte evaded capture.
Community Engagement and Artistic Tribute
Over the years, various narratives about the room have emerged, with students at Mount Carmel weaving their own tales about its use as a punishment space for misbehaving pupils. While the room and tunnel have been deemed unsafe for entry, a select few have been granted permission to view the area.
Local artist Paul Schexnayder, who attended the marker installation, showcased a painting inspired by the stories he learned about the tunnel. “I heard all kinds of stories about it,” Schexnayder remarked, reflecting the community’s deep-rooted connection to its folklore.
This event not only honors the legend of Jean Lafitte but also reinforces the importance of cultural heritage in shaping a community’s identity. The installation of the historical marker at Mount Carmel stands as a testament to New Iberia’s rich storytelling tradition and the ongoing efforts to celebrate its unique past.