Florida’s Executive Director for the Division of Emergency Management, Kevin Guthrie, publicly criticized Democratic lawmakers for allegedly exaggerating conditions at a new detention facility, informally dubbed “Alligator Alcatraz.” Guthrie made these statements during an appearance on Fox News on March 11, 2024, following a tour of the facility that included more than 60 lawmakers.
Guthrie described the situation as “very taxing,” noting that some legislators appeared to be trying to create controversy from what he considered manufactured issues. He recounted an incident where a lawmaker used an infrared thermometer to measure the temperature of a light bulb, claiming it read 110 degrees. Guthrie responded by suggesting they measure the ambient air temperature instead.
During the tour, Democrats raised concerns about the toilet facilities in the detention center. Guthrie defended the setup, stating that it met or exceeded both national and state standards. “This is a standard lock-up toilet system, that is in any secured facility,” he said. “We meet — and exceed — either the national standard or the state of Florida standard.”
When questioned about the quality of food served at the facility, Guthrie specifically addressed comments made by Democratic Representative Debbie Wasserman-Schultz. She criticized a turkey sandwich served at the center, which was reportedly wrapped and not visible at the time of her remarks. Guthrie remarked, “I don’t know how she could tell it was gray,” referencing the sandwich’s color. He also pointed out that similar meals are provided in hospitals and under Michelle Obama‘s school lunch program.
Guthrie’s comments highlight a growing divide between state officials and Democratic leaders regarding the enforcement of federal immigration laws. He suggested that opposition to strict enforcement may stem from a political strategy to appeal to potential voters. “If you break federal immigration law — and on top of that, you commit a violent crime — you shouldn’t expect to be sent to a resort with a debit card in hand,” he stated.
The facility, officially known as a detention center, aims to house individuals who have violated immigration laws. Guthrie emphasized the importance of adhering to legal immigration processes, stating, “If people don’t want to go there, then they should follow the law. Come to America the right way.” His remarks underscore a tougher stance on immigration enforcement compared to previous administrations.
As the debate continues, Guthrie’s comments provide insight into the ongoing discussions surrounding immigration policy and its political implications in Florida. The facility’s designation as “Alligator Alcatraz” reflects a broader narrative about the treatment of undocumented immigrants and the conditions under which they are held.
In a time when immigration remains a contentious issue, the claims made by both sides will likely continue to be scrutinized by officials and the public alike. The outcome of these discussions may have significant implications for future legislation and public perception in the realm of immigration policy.