Erie County Republicans achieved significant victories in the recent elections held on November 4, 2025, particularly in the Southtowns region. While the party faced setbacks in races such as the Amherst Town Supervisor and Erie County Comptroller, they secured key positions in suburban municipalities, including Hamburg and Orchard Park.
In a speech at the party’s election headquarters, Erie County Republican Committee Chairman Michael Kracker expressed pride in the accomplishments of local candidates. He highlighted the efforts of Daniel O’Connell, chair of the Hamburg Republican Committee, noting the years of dedication that led to the successful outcomes in the local races.
Strong performances were noted in Hamburg, where Beth Farrell Lorentz emerged victorious in the highly contested Town Supervisor race. Initial counts suggested a commanding lead for Democratic candidate Robert Reynolds, but as the night progressed, Lorentz gained momentum, ultimately winning by a narrow margin of just 111 votes.
“This was a resounding win for the taxpayers of Hamburg,” Lorentz stated during her victory speech. “I’m proud to represent Hamburg and the trust the residents have placed in us as their conservative Republican voice. We will listen and deliver on our promises.”
The Town Board elections in Hamburg also favored Republican candidates, with Lynn Dixon, a former Erie County Legislator, leading the vote count at 9,038. Fellow Republican Nicholas Ortiz followed closely with 7,792 votes. Both candidates successfully fended off challenges from their Democratic opponents, Megan Comerford and Jennifer Linsley.
“To the voters of Hamburg, I am proud to represent you,” Dixon remarked. “I am grateful for your support of my candidacy. I am excited to work alongside Beth and Nick on the board.”
In Orchard Park, the Republican Party continued its success, with candidates Julia Mombrea and Gregory Bennett winning two available Town Board seats. Additionally, Joseph Liberti triumphed in the Town Supervisor race, defeating Democratic challenger Marie Mahon by nearly 20 percentage points.
The election results reflect a shifting political landscape in Erie County, with the Republican Party making substantial inroads in suburban areas. The successes in Hamburg and Orchard Park signal a consolidation of power for the GOP, setting the stage for future legislative initiatives and community engagement. As these newly elected officials take office, they prepare to address the needs and concerns of their constituents while upholding the principles of their party.