Residents of Butler County, Ohio, united in a significant protest to demand the termination of the county’s contract with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). This rally took place on Tuesday outside a commissioners’ meeting in downtown Hamilton, prompted by the recent shooting of Renee Good by an ICE agent in Minneapolis. The tragic event heightened community concerns regarding the treatment and safety of detainees in local facilities.
Participants expressed their frustrations against the ICE contract during the meeting, which saw a notable turnout. Many speakers criticized the arrangement, urging the county commissioners to take decisive action in response to growing unrest in the community. One resident remarked, “It’s not a question of if killings occur in our Butler County, but when they occur during these ICE actions and tactics,” reflecting the heightened anxiety surrounding the issue.
The public comment section lasted over an hour, with numerous individuals making passionate appeals against the sheriff’s office’s relationship with ICE. This protest marked the 25th consecutive week of organized opposition by the Butler County Immigrant Justice (BCIJ) group at public meetings, as reported by WCPO.
Butler County Sheriff Richard Jones defended the ICE contracts, asserting that they are essential for maintaining public safety. “I’ve done this with five presidents, and I’ve done it through a whole load of commissioners, and judges and prosecutors, and guess what… the old sheriff is still here,” he stated during an interview with FOX19. His remarks were made in response to the mounting criticisms from residents.
County Commissioner Cindy Carpenter acknowledged the public’s concerns but clarified that the board does not possess the authority to dictate the operations of independently elected county officials. This statement appeared to distance the board from the operational decisions regarding ICE detainees, further complicating the situation.
Compounding the controversy are reports regarding conditions at the Butler County Jail. An inspection conducted in July 2025 revealed allegations of overcrowding, inadequate heating, and the use of punitive meals. Sheriff Jones dismissed these concerns as “the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen in my life,” and mockingly referred to the Democratic state lawmakers who raised the issue as “the three stooges,” according to the Journal-News.
The ongoing debate illustrates the growing tension between local officials and residents regarding the ICE contract. Protesters remain steadfast, believing that their collective voice holds power. One protester stated, “Yes, (the Sheriff) has power, but our voices do, too,” emphasizing the determination of the community to effect change.
Looking ahead, the Butler County Immigrant Justice organization plans to continue attending commissioners’ meetings in pursuit of ending the contract with ICE. This ongoing engagement highlights the residents’ commitment to addressing their concerns over detainee treatment and safety, reflecting a broader movement within the community to advocate for policy changes.