The Denver Broncos’ offense has struggled significantly, leading to questions about the effectiveness of head coach Sean Payton. After a disappointing defeat against the Los Angeles Chargers on September 21, 2025, the team’s performance has raised concerns about their identity and strategy on the field.
Despite their current 1-2 record, the Broncos’ upcoming schedule may provide some relief, as their next seven opponents have a combined record of 7-14. However, the urgency for improvement is evident, especially with the offense’s lackluster performance. The team has yet to establish a clear offensive strategy, with many observers pointing to Payton‘s play-calling as a significant factor in this confusion.
Throughout training camp, Payton emphasized the necessity of a strong start to the season. Yet, three games in, the Broncos have failed to exhibit any offensive consistency. Following their second consecutive loss, there is growing frustration among fans and players alike, as no one seems to have a clear understanding of what the team excels at offensively.
In discussing the recent game, Payton noted, “I think it was too inconsistent. The thing that stood out was not only the penalties that set you back but the minus plays. That has to be corrected for us to be a quality offense.” These remarks underscore the pressing need for the Broncos to adapt their offense to better suit their personnel rather than relying on a predetermined system.
Statistical analysis reveals the depth of the Broncos’ struggles. According to data from Sharp Football, the team ranks last in first- and second-down success this season. Their running game has been ineffective, averaging just 3 yards per carry in the first half of games, with only 18% of those plays gaining five or more yards. This lack of productivity is particularly puzzling given that the offensive line ranks 10th in run block win rate.
The disconnect between the offensive line’s performance and the overall offensive strategy has led to questions about Payton‘s approach. The offensive linemen have expressed their commitment to setting the tone during practices and games. Yet, they feel stifled by a lack of emphasis on the running game, which requires time and conviction to develop effectively.
In the recent game against the Chargers, the Broncos’ running back, Dobbins, emerged as a bright spot, rushing for 83 yards on seven carries. His performance highlights the potential for a more effective ground attack, especially since he ranks third in yards after contact per rush, according to Pro Football Network data.
As the Broncos look to regain their footing, Payton must find a way to build on the strengths of his best offensive players. Right guard Quinn Meinerz, left tackle Garett Bolles, and Dobbins have been standout performers and should be central to any offensive strategy moving forward.
The urgency to define a successful offensive identity is palpable. The Broncos need to develop a cohesive plan that maximizes their players’ talents and adapts to the current roster. As the season progresses, it remains to be seen whether Payton can pivot from his initial vision and cultivate an offense that can effectively compete in the league.
The upcoming games will be crucial as the Broncos aim to bounce back and establish a more consistent and effective offensive approach. With the right adjustments, the team can shift from their current struggles to a season that meets their potential.