The Toronto Blue Jays are grappling with uncertainty in their pitching rotation as the playoffs approach. As of September 30, 2023, the team boasts an impressive record of 89-65, leading the American League and holding a three-game advantage over the New York Yankees and a five-game lead over the Boston Red Sox in the AL East standings. Despite this strong position, recent performances have cast doubt on the reliability of their pitching staff.
The top three spots in the Blue Jays’ rotation appear secure, with pitchers Kevin Gausman, Shane Bieber, and Chris Bassitt expected to take the mound in the postseason. However, the fourth starter remains a critical question mark following the alarming performance of Max Scherzer.
In a disheartening outing against the Kansas City Royals, Scherzer struggled significantly, contributing to the Blue Jays’ overwhelming 20-1 defeat. He failed to complete the first inning, surrendering seven runs on seven hits, which included two home runs. Scherzer also issued one walk while striking out two batters, managing to record just two outs before being pulled from the game. This latest performance marks a continuation of a troubling trend for the veteran pitcher.
Over his last five starts, Scherzer has allowed a staggering 21 runs on 27 hits, which includes seven home runs and eight walks. His earned run average (ERA) has surged from 3.60 to 5.06 during this span, raising concerns within the Blue Jays’ coaching staff about his ability to deliver in crucial moments.
With Scherzer’s struggles becoming increasingly pronounced, the Blue Jays are left searching for a reliable option to fill the fourth starter position in their playoff rotation. The team had previously moved pitchers Jose Berrios and Eric Lauer to the bullpen, but Berrios could potentially return to the rotation if needed. The situation is further complicated by the limited experience of Trey Yesavage, the club’s top prospect, who made an impressive debut in Major League Baseball. Yesavage may only have the opportunity for two or three starts before the playoffs commence.
As the regular season draws to a close, the Blue Jays are in urgent need of a pitcher to step up and solidify their postseason plans. The timing of Scherzer’s downturn in form could not be more challenging, as the team prepares for a critical stretch in their quest for playoff success. The coming days will determine whether Scherzer can regain his form or if Toronto will need to seek alternative solutions for their rotation.