MONTREAL – The 2025 NHL Draft’s inaugural decentralized format left many feeling disconnected from the event’s usual excitement.
The first round of the 2025 NHL Draft was not without its highlights. Matthew Schaefer experienced a wave of emotions as he was selected No. 1 overall by the New York Islanders. Celebrities announced team picks, and two goaltenders were chosen in the first round, a rarity in itself. Additionally, the sons of Shawn Horcoff and Jenny Potter were drafted, and a significant trade between the Islanders and the Montreal Canadiens preceded the event.
Immediate Impact
Despite these highlights, the night felt different. This marked the NHL’s first decentralized draft outside of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the change was palpable. The topic was addressed during NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman’s pre-draft news conference, where he urged patience, suggesting the new format be given a chance. However, many hope for a return to the traditional format.
Key Details Emerge
Winners of the First Round
- Matthew Schaefer: The Erie Otters defenseman, who faced personal tragedies and injuries, was ranked first by NHL Central Scouting and ultimately selected by the Islanders. His emotional response on stage, marked by a pink ribbon on his jersey, highlighted his journey.
- James Hagens: Initially a top pick contender, Hagens fell to sixth place, joining the Boston Bruins. The announcement by actor Adam Sandler added a personal touch, as Hagens is a fan of “Happy Gilmore.”
- Roger McQueen’s Disney Adventure: Drafted 10th overall by the Anaheim Ducks, McQueen’s selection was announced by actors from the “Mighty Ducks” movies, followed by a helicopter ride to Disneyland.
- Crowd’s Reaction to Johnny Gaudreau’s Widow: Meredith Gaudreau, announcing the Columbus Blue Jackets’ picks, received a standing ovation, underscoring the emotional depth of the event.
Losers of the First Round
- The Format: Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly noted the vote to decentralize was 26-6, aimed at saving travel days and planning time. However, the absence of the traditional draft floor’s dynamic energy was missed.
- Lack of Player Trades: Despite early intrigue, the first round saw only draft picks traded, continuing a recent trend of limited player movement.
- Ken Holland’s Draft Strategy: The Los Angeles Kings’ GM chose to move down in the draft, a decision met with mixed reactions from fans.
- GM of the Year Vote: Dallas Stars’ Jim Nill won for the third consecutive year, sparking debate over whether Panthers GM Bill Zito deserved the honor for his impactful acquisitions.
Industry Response
The announcement comes as the NHL seeks to modernize its processes, yet the decentralized format has drawn comparisons to other leagues, with many fans and analysts longing for the traditional, centralized draft experience.
By the Numbers
26-6: Vote count in favor of decentralizing the draft.
2: Number of goaltenders selected in the first round, an uncommon occurrence.
3: Consecutive years Jim Nill has won GM of the Year.
What Comes Next
The NHL’s decision to decentralize the draft represents a significant shift from past traditions. As the league evaluates the format’s success, fans and teams alike await potential adjustments in future drafts. The timing is particularly significant as teams prepare for the upcoming free agency period, with the draft’s outcomes influencing strategic decisions.
According to sources familiar with the league’s plans, discussions are ongoing about the format’s future. Meanwhile, industry experts warn that maintaining fan engagement will be crucial as the NHL navigates these changes.
The move represents a significant shift from the traditional draft, and its long-term impact on the league remains to be seen. As the NHL continues to evolve, the balance between innovation and tradition will be at the forefront of future decisions.